Timothy Wiltsey was just five years old when he vanished from a carnival in Sayreville, New Jersey, on May 25, 1991. His disappearance sparked a massive search and a mystery that captivated the nation. Nearly a year later, Timothy’s remains were found in a remote area, and his mother, Michelle Lodzinski, became the prime suspect.
The Disappearance
On that fateful Memorial Day weekend, Michelle Lodzinski reported Timothy missing from a carnival she had attended with him. She claimed she had briefly left him unattended to buy a soda, and when she returned, he was gone. Her story quickly unraveled as inconsistencies emerged. Witnesses’ accounts contradicted her version of events, and her behavior raised suspicions.
She had supposedly spent the day of his disappearance at a local park, but the parking lot she claimed to use was closed that day. A witness claimed to have spoken to her that day and there was no child with her. Speaking to a friend, she said a woman named Ellen, along with two men, had kidnapped him. The next day, when she spoke to police, she repeated a similar story but added that one of the men threatened her with a knife.
The investigation into Timothy’s disappearance intensified, with law enforcement agencies and volunteers scouring the area for any sign of the little boy. Michelle Lodzinski’s demeanor during interviews and press conferences further fueled doubts about her innocence. She appeared detached and unemotional, failing to display the anguish one would expect from a mother whose child was missing.
The Discovery
Five months after the disappearance, a local birdwatcher discovered a small Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles shoe in a park across the river from Sayreville. Investigators thought it might be Timothy’s, but Lodzinzki said it did not belong to her son.
Several weeks later, a newspaper published a front-page story about the shoe and possible FBI forensic testing. Lodzinzki then called the police and claimed she had forgotten and the shoe might belong to her son after all.
During March and April of 1992, investigators re-interviewed many witnesses, hoping to find something they had overlooked. During this process, it was discovered that Michelle Lodzinzki had worked at the Raritan Center, where the shoe had been found, and had not mentioned that to the police when discussing her employment history. Former colleagues said she often took walks in the area during breaks.
In April 1992, police conducted another, more thorough search of the area. Timothy’s partial skeletal remains were found. Several items were found with him, including his clothing, a Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles balloon, and pillowcase. A large blue blanket was found near the remains, but Michelle Lodzinski claimed to have never seen it before.
The Waiting
For over 20 years, the case went unsolved. Investigators strongly suspected Michelle Lodzinski but didn’t have enough to move forward with the case. There was no physical evidence directly tying her to the crime, and no witnesses had seen her harm her son.
In 2011, the Middlesex County Prosecutor’s Office reopened the investigation into Timothy Wiltsey’s murder. Advances in forensic technology and the re-examination of old evidence led to a renewed focus on Michelle Lodzinski.
They immediately took note of the blanket. Investigators were certain that he would not have had it with him at the fair on a day when the temperature was 90 degrees, and did something that no one had done in 1992 – they showed the blanket to some of Timothy’s former babysitters. Two different babysitters recognized it, one saying that it was one of his favorites and another describing snuggling with him wrapped in the blanket.
The Arrest, Conviction, and Appeal
On August 6, 2014, Michelle Lodzinski was arrested for Timothy’s murder. The trial began in March of 2016, 24 years after Timothy’s body was found. This time, the prosecution presented a strong but circumstantial case, highlighting the inconsistencies in her story, the witness testimony, and the significance of the blue blanket.
After hearing the testimony of 68 different witnesses, a jury found Michelle Lodzinski guilty of Timothy’s murder. She was sentenced to 30 years in prison without the possibility of parole.
The conviction brought a sense of closure to a case that had haunted the community for decades, but those who thought they could breathe a sigh of relief were mistaken.
She appealed to the state Appellate Division, claiming that the 23-year delay before trial was unfair, but her appeal was denied in 2019. She then appealed to the State Supreme Court of New Jersey. In October of 2021, her appeal was granted. Lodzinski was released from prison on December 28.
It is important to note that the appeal did not find her factually innocent. Judge Albin wrote in the Court’s decision that there was no evidence “that Lodzinski purposely or knowingly caused Timothy’s death”. To be convicted of murder in New Jersey, it has to be shown that the death was caused intentionally. Had she been convicted of the lesser included charges of reckless or negligent homicide, the guilty verdict would have been upheld.
Conclusion
The murder of Timothy Wiltsey is a heartbreaking story of a young life cut short. The case captivated the nation and raised important questions about justice, accountability, and the protection of children. While Michelle Lodzinski’s initial conviction brought some closure, her release after appeal brought renewed heartache to many. It is likely that the full truth about Timothy’s death may never be known.
Timothy Wiltsey’s story serves as a poignant reminder of the preciousness of life and the importance of safeguarding the innocence of childhood. Michelle Lodzinski’s relearse sets a dangerous precedent. If someone is clearly guilty, should they be allowed to go free because of a technical error? What kind of changes need to happen in our justice system?
Sources:
- This article on MyCentralJersey.com has great information, including a helpful timeline.
- This article from nj.com has a lot of information and pictures.
The Crime Chronicles 
Leave a comment